NSTA - National Science Teachers Association

Member Login

Science StoreView Cart   View Cart

Scientific Argumentation in Biology: 30 Classroom Activities (e-book)


By: Victor Sampson and Sharon Schleigh

$25.97 - Member Price  
$29.96 - Nonmember Price


$41.55 - Member Price  
$51.94 - Nonmember Price

Details

Type of Product:e-Book (our e-books are in PDF format and can be viewed on your computer or any compatible reading device) (also see print version of this book)
Pages:417
Stock Number:PB304Xe
ISBN:978-1-936959-56-3
Grade Level:Middle School, High School


Description

“Individuals who are proficient in science should be able to understand the language of science and participate in scientific practices, such as inquiry and argumentation. Empirical research, however, indicates that many students do not develop this knowledge or these abilities in school. One way to address this problem is to give students more opportunities to engage in scientific argumentation as part of the teaching and learning of science. This book will help teachers with this task.” —Authors Victor Sampson and Sharon Schleigh

Develop your high school students’ understanding of argumentation and evidence-based reasoning with this comprehensive book. Like three guides in one, Scientific Argumentation in Biology combines theory, practice, and biology content.

It starts by giving you solid background in why students need to be able to go beyond expressing mere opinions when making research-related biology claims. Then it provides 30 thoroughly field-tested activities your students can use when learning to:
• propose, support, and evaluate claims;
• validate or refute them on the basis of scientific reasoning; and
• craft complex written arguments.

Detailed teacher notes suggest specific ways in which you can use the activities to enrich and supplement (not replace) what you’re doing in biology class already.
Scientific Argumentation is an invaluable resource for learning more about argumentation and designing related lessons. You'll find it ideal for helping your students learn standards-based content; improve their biological practices; explain, interpret, and evaluate evidence; and acquire the habits of mind to become more proficient in science.


Ideas For Use

Additional Info

Intended User Role:Elementary-Level Educator, High-School Educator, Middle-Level Educator, Teacher
Educational Issues:Assessment of students, Classroom management, Curriculum, Inquiry learning, Instructional materials, Interdisciplinary, Teacher preparation, Teaching strategies

Contents

Preface
What Is Scientific Argumentation?
Why Integrate Argumentation Into the Teaching and Learning of Biology?
Development of the Activities

Introduction

Generate an Argument Instructional Model
Stage 1: The Identification of the Problem and the Research Question
Stage 2: The Generation of a Tentative Argument
Stage 3: The Argumentation Session
Stage 4: A Reflective Discussion
Stage 5: The Production of a Final Written Argument

Evaluate Alternatives Instructional Model
Stage 1: Introduce the Phenomenon to Investigate, the Research Question, and the Alternative Explanations
Stage 2: The Generation of Data
Stage 3: The Generation of Tentative Arguments and Counterarguments
Stage 4: An Argumentation Session
Stage 5: The Reflective Discussion
Stage 6: The Production of a Final Written Argument

Refutational Writing Activities
The Activities in This Book
How to Use the Activities
The Role of the Teacher During the Activities
Assessments

Teacher Notes
Purpose
The Content and Related Concepts
Curricular and Instructional Considerations
Recommendations for Implementing the Activity
Assessment
Framework Matrices
References

Generate an Argument
Framework Matrix
Activity 1: Classifying Birds in the United States (Species Concept)
Activity 2: Color Variation in Venezuelan Guppies (Mechanisms of Evolution)
Activity 3: Desert Snakes (Mechanics of Evolution)
Activity 4: Fruit Fly Traits (Genetics)
Activity 5: DNA Family Relationship Analysis (Genetics)
Activity 6: Evolutionary Relationships in Mammals (Genetics and Evolution)
Activity 7: Decline in Saltwater Fish Populations (Ecology and Human Impact on the Environment)
Activity 8: History of Life on Earth (Trends in Evolution)
Activity 9: Surviving Winter in the Dust Bowl (Food Chains and Trophic Levels)
Activity 10: Characteristics of Viruses (Characteristics of Life)

Evaluate Alternatives
Framework Matrix
Activity 11: Spontaneous Generation (Cell Theory)
Activity 12: Plant Biomass (Photosynthesis)
Activity 13: Movement of Molecules in or out of Cells (Osmosis and Diffusion)
Activity 14: Liver and Hydrogen Peroxide (Chemical Reactions and Catalysts)
Activity 15: Cell Size and Diffusion (Diffusion)
Activity 16: Environmental Influence on Genotypes and Phenotypes (Genetics)
Activity 17: Hominid Evolution (Macroevolution)
Activity 18: Plants and Energy (Respiration and Photosynthesis)
Activity 19: Healthy Diet and Weight (Human Health)
Activity 20: Termite Trails (Animal Behavior)

Refutational Writing
Framework Matrix
Activity 21: Misconception About Theories and Laws (Nature of Science)
Activity 22: Misconception About the Nature of Scientific Knowledge (Nature of Science)
Activity 23: Misconception About the Work of Scientists (Nature of Science)
Activity 24: Misconception About the Methods of Investigations (Nature of Science)
Activity 25: Misconception About Life on Earth (Evolution)
Activity 26: Misconception About Bacteria (Microbiology)
Activity 27: Misconception About Interactions That Take Place Between Organisms (Ecology)
Activity 28: Misconception About Plant Reproduction (Botany)
Activity 29: Misconception About Inheritance of Traits (Genetics)
Activity 30: Misconception About Insects (Ecology)
Assessments and Student Samples
Generate an Argument Samples
Evaluate Alternatives Samples
Refutational Writing Samples

Appendix
Index


Customers who bought this item also bought
22% Uncovering Student Ideas in Life Science, Volume 1: 25 New Formative Assessment Probes (e-book)
Member Price: $19.47 Nonmember Price: $22.46

16% The Biology Teacher's Handbook, 4th Edition (e-book)
Member Price: $19.47 Nonmember Price: $22.46

15% Hard-to-Teach Biology Concepts: A Framework to Deepen Student Understanding (e-book)
Member Price: $22.07 Nonmember Price: $25.46

12% Uncovering Student Ideas in Physical Science, Volume 1: 45 New Force and Motion Assessment Probes (e-book)
Member Price: $22.72 Nonmember Price: $26.21

12% Climate Change From Pole to Pole: Biology Investigations (e-Book)
Member Price: $12.97 Nonmember Price: $14.96

National Standards Correlation

This resource has not yet been aligned with the National Standards.



Customer Reviews

This resource has not yet been reviewed by a customer.

If you wish to review this resource, click here.

All