Skip to main content
 

Oak Clearcutting

To Cut or Not to Cut

By Thomas A. Davis

Oak Clearcutting


 

Abstract

The topic of this debate case, developed for a course in “Issues in Environmental Biology,” is clear-cutting, a controversial method of harvesting and regenerating trees in which all trees are cleared from a site. Students debate the issue, assuming the roles of various stakeholders, including landowners, loggers, state foresters, soil conservation specialists, deer control specialists, and tree farm owners. After the debate, each student in the class must write an opinion paper on whether to clear-cut or not and give reasons that support their decision.

   

Date Posted

02/19/2006

Overview

Objectives

  • Diiscuss both sides of a contemporary environmental issue.
  • Understand how  science is involved in producing data and information that is vital to making a decision.
  • Write essay defending a position.
  • See how the scientific method, equipment, data, and its results are used to solve everyday environmental problems.
  • Interpret scientific data and apply it to understand and help solve an environmental problem.

Keywords

Tree farming; clearcutting; clear cutting; timber; natural resource conservation; soil conservation; forest products; logging; deer management; white oak

  

Subject Headings

Botany / Plant Science
Environmental Science
Forestry
Natural Resource Management

EDUCATIONAL LEVEL

Undergraduate lower division, Undergraduate upper division

  

FORMAT

PDF

   

TOPICAL AREAS

Scientific argumentation

   

LANGUAGE

English

   

TYPE/METHODS

Debate, Role-Play

 

 

Asset 2