Teaching Through Trade Books
By Christine Anne Royce
All around us are opportunities to observe forces and interactions between objects. For younger students, two toy cars crashing into one another may simply be a game, but this activity can also be used to help them understand a key physical science concept. For intermediate students, ideas about how much force needs to be applied to hit a baseball start to make sense. The books selected for this month focus on different types of interactions between objects and ask students to consider what happens when a force is applied to an object. Does it stop? Does it change direction? Which force is stronger? How does gravity affect the object?
To describe how a push or a pull is a force and that different forces affect an object’s motion and direction.
Show students the cover of Oscar and the Cricket: A Book About Moving and Rolling and start a discussion about how things move. Ask students, “If you had a ball, how or when would it start to roll?” Accept all student ideas initially. Then, read the story to students and focus on the following key points:
Teacher setup note: Before starting this activity, place three strips of painter’s tape on the floor approximately one foot apart to serve as the target lines for this activity. To make the third event easier, place the third strip of tape (the one farthest from students) approximately two feet away from a wall or low obstacle such as a board. Also place painter’s tape on the floor as a start line. Divide students into partners and take them to a multipurpose room, a gymnasium, or a wide hallway where multiple students will be able to roll balls on a smooth surface. Model for students what they will be aiming for within the target area during the push and pull events.
Using the same type of ball, such as a small rubber one similar to what Oscar used or even kickballs, ask the pairs of students to sit behind the starting line and place their ball on the starting line. Explain to them that their task is to use force to get the ball to stop between the first and second line of painter’s tape. Have them discuss with their partner what they know about pushing as a force and then allow each student to push the ball so that it rolls forward and stops. Tell students to think about how they push the ball and how hard they push the ball this first time. Allow each student to try to hit the target.
Using painter’s tape, mark the spots where each student’s ball came to rest with his or her name. Ask students to make observations about how far their ball rolled, in which direction it rolled (e.g., did it roll straight ahead?), and compare to their partner’s roll. Questions to ask include, “Which roll went farther, yours or your partner’s?” and “Did the ball stop before the target area, in the target area, or after the target area?” Ask students to return to the starting line and make comparison statements between their roll and their partner’s on their Event Record Sheet (see NSTA Connection). Have them determine what they need to do to hit the target on their second attempt.
Ask them to repeat the process of pushing the ball so that it rolls forward. Then ask students to return to their Event Record Sheet and record their observations for the second roll.
Locate several books that weigh about 10 pounds, tape them onto plastic scooter boards from your school’s physical education department, and tie a rope to one of the handles. This will allow students to pull the board forward so that it moves and maintains the same amount of weight. Ask students to consider whether they should use a push or a pull to move the scooter with the books. Their constraints are that they must use the rope and cannot touch the scooter. Ask them to discuss with their partner which idea they think would work best and why. Let them test their idea first and then test additional ideas for comparison. Ask them to compare on their Event Record Sheet how pulling the scooter is similar to how Oscar had to pull the tree branch out of the way.
Return to the first event setup and add either a low wall made from a 2” × 18” piece of wood or an actual wall. Remind students that in the story, Oscar watched his ball bounce back toward him when it hit the tree. In this event, they are trying to get their ball to roll forward, hit the wall, and then stop in the target area. Model this for students and, depending on where your ball stops, ask students to discuss what might have been done differently, such as rolling the ball with more or less force. Once again, mark the spot where each student’s ball stopped with painter’s tape for comparison and discussion purposes. Allow each team to repeat the process from Event 1 (i.e., trial, recording the outcome, discussion of results, and a second attempt).
Most students will not hit the exact target, which is fine. The point of this Explore activity is for students to consider whether they should use a push or a pull to accomplish an activity and how much force should be applied.
Involve students in a discussion about their observations and conclusions from the Explore activity. Hang the Decision Signs (see NSTA Connection) in different gathering locations around the classroom. Have students move to a particular area of the room based on their answer to the following questions, so that they are divided into groups for each topic. For the first event, the teacher can say to students:
“How many of you had your ball stop before the target in the first activity? Please go to the side of the room marked ‘before the target.’ Those who had their ball go farther than the target, please find the location in the room marked ‘farther than the target.’ Those who hit the target, please form a group where it says ‘on target.’ Now that you are in your groups, please discuss with each other what happened or how far your ball went. What conclusion did you arrive at based on where the ball stopped? How would you need to change your second attempt?”
Once individual groups of students have discussed their ideas, draw them back into a whole-class discussion to see whether the ideas make sense to everyone.
Have students repeat this process with the next two activities, one at a time. Change the signs to represent the decisions from each. For the second event, the signs are “push the scooter first” and “pull the scooter first.” The signs for the third event are, “ball didn’t hit the wall,” “ball hit the wall and stopped short of the target,” “ball hit the wall and stopped farther than the target,” and “ball hit the wall and stopped in the target.”
The Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS Lead States 2013) website features multiple ideas for activities related to the topic of forces and interactions. One such activity, Push and Pull Sorting Cards (see Internet Resources), asks students to consider a variety of everyday objects and actions that require pushing, pulling, or both to cause the objects to work or move. Hold up one of the cards and pose the following questions to students:
For example, one of the pictures is a person playing the piano. The interaction that happens is between the child and the piano keys when the child pushes down on them to make a sound. Students may also say that the piano keys are pushing up on the person’s fingers, but with a weaker force than the child is pushing down. Depending on students’ age or understanding about how a piano works, they might also say that there is an interaction between the piano’s pedals and the child, or between the strings and hammers.
Ask students, as a whole class (with younger students) or in small groups (with older students), to discuss whether each object can be pushed, pulled, or both to make it work. Ask students to discuss the three labels of “push,” “pull,” and “push and pull” and then sort appropriately. Have students explain their reasoning for placing each card in its category. (Teachers should note that many pictures could be placed in different categories depending on how the object is used or whether students describe more than the most basic actions. Therefore, the need for students to explain their reasoning is important.) Finally, ask students to select one of the objects and illustrate it on their student sheet.
Students make connections to Oscar and Cricket to describe their understanding of pushing and pulling, and how both of these are forces. After using forces to accomplish tasks, students discuss their findings and adapt their actions to using less or more force in second attempts. Finally, they exhibit their understanding of how force is used with daily objects.
To observe how gravity interacts with different objects and determine that gravity pulls objects toward the center of the Earth.
Pose the following question to students and allow them to discuss their ideas: “When something is dropped or falls from a high place, does it always fall downward?” Once students have discussed their ideas, show them several video clips (see Internet Resources) in the following order and discuss each:
Hopefully at some point during this discussion, students will mention the word gravity. If they do not, introduce the term yourself. Then, ask students whether they can describe what gravity is in their own words.
Using the activity on page 32 of Gravity Is a Mystery, have students investigate how gravity affects objects of the same and of different shapes. Hold up two different balls, such as a Ping-Pong ball and a baseball, and ask students what they think will happen if the balls are dropped from the same height. Ask them to consider factors that might impact how the objects fall. Their weight is often the first idea that students come up with, so allow them to weigh the balls on a scale and record their information.
Then, give each group of students a set of materials including a Ping-Pong ball, baseball, meterstick, and the Falling for Gravity Student Data Sheet (see NSTA Connection). Let them test the question of what happens to the balls when they are dropped from the same height. Model a technique to help them drop both balls at the same time: They should lay their arms across a desk so that their arms are at the same height and then have a single student serve as the person who counts down to the drop. Next, ask students to drop the Ping-Pong ball and a sheet of paper held flat, and record their results. Finally, ask them to drop the Ping-Pong ball and a sheet of paper crumpled into a ball. At this point, ask students to compare their notes and determine whether they think the weight of an object affects how fast it falls and in what direction. (Teachers note: Each object has weight based on its mass and the interaction of gravity with its mass.) Tell groups to return to their student sheet and draw conclusions about the results of their investigation.
Read Gravity Is a Mystery to the class in its entirety, and then return to the following points to guide discussion:
Tell students that they have been hired by NASA to create informational posters on gravity for other schools. Ask students to use the Informational Poster Sheet (see NSTA Connection) to create a poster that explains gravity in their own words, includes a picture that represents gravity’s effect on objects and people, and highlights two benefits that exist because of gravity.
Gravity is an elusive concept for students; however, in this set of investigations, students make connections between gravity and falling objects. Students then test how gravity affects objects.
Students, after trial and error, revise their ideas about how much force they need to use to get a ball into a target area.
PS2.B: Types of Interactions
The gravitational force of Earth acting on an object near Earth’s surface pulls that object toward the planet’s center.
Students discuss with their peers how their results could have been made more accurate.
Students explain how objects require force to be used in daily life and discuss whether those forces are a push or a pull.
K-PS2-2. Analyze data to determine if a design solution works as intended to change the speed or direction of an object with a push or pull.
Students investigate whether objects with different weights but the same shape hit the ground at the same time, versus objects with different weights and different shapes.
Students create informational posters explaining gravity and providing a visual diagram of what it does.
PS2.B: Types of Interactions
The gravitational force of Earth acting on an object near Earth’s surface pulls that object toward the planet’s center.
Students connect the idea of gravity to real-life examples in which gravity is pulling objects/people toward the Earth’s center.
Students consider why it is easier for astronauts to jump or move objects on the Moon than on Earth.
5-PS2-1. Support an argument that the gravitational force exerted by Earth on objects is directed down.
This section provides the Common Core for English Language Arts and/or Mathematics standards addressed in this column to allow for cross-curricular planning and integration. The Standards state that students should be able to do the following at grade level.
Reading Standards for Informational Texts K–5 – Key Ideas and Details
Writing Standards K–5 – Research to Build and Present Knowledge
Writing Standards K–5 – Text Types and Purposes
Speaking and Listening Standards K–5 – Comprehension and Collaboration
Speaking and Listening Standards K–5 – Presentation of Knowledge and Ideas
Vocabulary Acquisition and Use is one of the standards for language. This particular standard is across grade levels: “Determine or clarify the meaning of unknown and multiple-meaning words and phrases based on grade [appropriate] reading and content.”Furthermore, the Common Core for ELA provide a standard related to the Range of Text Types for K–5 where it indicates that students in K–5 should apply the Reading standards to a wide range of texts to include informational science books.
National Governors Association Center for Best Practices and Council of Chief State School Officers (NGAC and CCSSO). 2010. Common core state standards. Washington, DC: NGAC and CCSSO.
NGSS Lead States. 2013. Next Generation Science Standards: For states, by states. Washington, DC: National Academies Press. www.nextgenscience.org/next-generation-sciencestandards.
Journal ArticleFamily Science Clubs
Educators are increasingly recognizing that significant amounts of science learning take place over the course of one’s lifetime and that much of th...
Journal ArticleQ: What Can My Students See During the Upcoming Solar Eclipses?
A: It depends on where you are located. But first let’s briefly review what happens during a solar eclipse and clear up a few popular misconceptions...
Journal ArticleMaking the Most of Field Trips
Field trips can be a unique way to engage elementary students in science content. However, budget cuts and a focus on standardized testing are causing...