Skip to main content
 

Modern Frankenstein?

The Science and Social Science of Organ Replacement

By Susan Nava-Whitehead, Kerri W. Augusto, Korryna A. Finkelstein, Shianna Cruz, Joel Clark

Modern Frankenstein?


 

Abstract

This interdisciplinary case study uses the format of a progressive disclosure to explore certain advances in biotechnology and evaluate them within the framework of societal needs, concerns and pressures.  When faced with a heart valve transplant, a high school student and her mother must decide between multiple approaches, some current and others emergent. Highlighted in this case study are the topics of xenotransplantation, 3D bioprinting and the mature minor rule. The case includes a role-playing, public hearing activity that can be used to explore many aspects at the interface of technology and culture: religious rights, parental rights, public health care policy and safety, animal rights, economic issues of organ marketing, and psychological issues of body image.  This case study was originally designed for first year collegiate classes (introduction to biology, introduction to psychology) but is also applicable to AP high school. The flexible nature of the case also allows for expansion of several aspects for advanced classes across multiple disciplines.

   

Date Posted

03/05/2018

Overview

Objectives

  • Recognize the signs and symptoms of endocarditis.
  • Explore the various forms of organ transplantation with an emphasis on evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of mechanical vs. biological heart value transplantation.
  • Examine the criteria that should be used to define a young person as a mature minor in the context of medical decisions.
  • Describe the following as they relate to organ transplantation:
    • Biological: xenotransplantation, stereolithographic 3D bioprinting, stem cells, cloning, vascularization, totipotency, immunorejection, zoonotic disease.
    • Psychological: cognitive development, psychosocial development, identity development, moral development, bereavement, body integrity disorder.
    • Legal: mature minor, capacity, competence, statute, common law, competing interest.

Keywords

organ replacement; xenotransplantation; 3D bioprinting; body integrity disorder, mature minor; bioethics;

  

Subject Headings

Biology (General)
Biomedical Engineering
Biotechnology
Interdisciplinary Sciences
Psychology
Public Health
Science (General)

EDUCATIONAL LEVEL

High school, Undergraduate lower division

  

FORMAT

PDF

   

TOPICAL AREAS

Ethics, Legal issues

   

LANGUAGE

English

   

TYPE/METHODS

Dilemma/Decision, Interrupted, Public Hearing

 

 

Asset 2