Skip to main content
 

STEM Education Coalition Testifies before House Science Committee on Draft Bill to Reauthorize Federal STEM Education Programs

By Jodi Peterson

Posted on 2013-11-15

The House Subcommittee on Research and Technology began work on reauthorization of the America COMPETES Act with a hearing on Wednesday, November 13. Lawmakers are reviewing draft legislation introduced by committee Republicans to reauthorize this key legislation, which will coordinate federal STEM education programs and reauthorize research and science programs at the National Science Foundation (NSF), National Institutes for Standards and Technology (NIST), and the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP).
The STEM Education Coalition was invited to testify before the House Science Committee and share their views on the coordination of federal STEM education programs included in the Republican draft bill, which is titled the “Frontiers in Innovation Research, Science and Technology (FIRST) Act.”
In regards to STEM education, language in the FIRST Act:

  • Prohibits NSF and NIST from implementing OMB-directed reorganization of STEM education-related  programs set forth in the FY 2014 budget request—in order to ensure better stakeholder input;
  • Authorizes CoSTEM to consider priority areas for federal STEM funding and creates STEM Education Coordinating Office in the NSF Directorate for Education and Human Resources to support efforts for outcome-oriented STEM programs
  • Creates a new STEM Education Advisory Panel to be comprised of stakeholders from education and industry sectors; and
  • Recognizes importance of industry investment in STEM education.

The testimony presented by the James Brown, Executive Director of the STEM Education Coalition (NSTA chairs the Coalition) focused on issues related to the coordination and management of federal STEM education programs and the importance of stakeholder input into those plans. In his testimony Brown told lawmakers that “STEM education must be elevated as a national policy priority as reflected through education reforms, policies to drive innovation, and budgetary priorities,” and that “action on STEM education policy should match the rhetoric on its importance.”
In testimony, Brown also told the committee that “the federal STEM education portfolio is in need of a serious overhaul. There are currently more than 200 STEM education programs scattered across 13 different agencies, a huge portion of which fall under the jurisdiction of the Committee. A large fraction of these programs are quite small in scope. On the other end of the spectrum, the Department of Education’s Math and Science Partnership program—the largest federal program that is focused solely on STEM outcomes—has not been reauthorized in more than a decade. Many federal programs have limited data on outcomes and effectiveness and all of the programs in the current federal portfolio would benefit from greater cross-agency coordination and a better system of evaluation.”
Read the testimony submitted by the STEM Education Coalition.
Webcast of the hearing: See it here.
Read Press Releases about the hearing:
Republican release
Democratic release
Read coverage of the hearing:
FIRST Up: Lawmakers to Examine Bill Renewing U.S. Research (ScienceInsider)
House Hearing Skates over Big Disagreements on NSF Reauthorization (ScienceInsider)

Jodi Peterson is the Assistant Executive Director, Communications, Legislative, and Public Affairs for the National Science Teachers Association; and the Chair, STEM Education Coalition

The House Subcommittee on Research and Technology began work on reauthorization of the America COMPETES Act with a hearing on Wednesday, November 13. Lawmakers are reviewing draft legislation introduced by committee Republicans to reauthorize this key legislation, which will coordinate federal STEM education programs and reauthorize research and science programs at the National Science Foundation (NSF), National Institutes for Standards and Technology (NIST), and the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP).

Here’s the ideal statistics book for teachers with no statistics background. Written in an informal style with easy-to-grasp examples, The Basics of Data Literacy teaches you how to help your students understand data. Then, in turn, they learn how to collect, summarize, and analyze statistics inside and outside the classroom.
Here’s the ideal statistics book for teachers with no statistics background. Written in an informal style with easy-to-grasp examples, The Basics of Data Literacy teaches you how to help your students understand data. Then, in turn, they learn how to collect, summarize, and analyze statistics inside and outside the classroom.
The arrival of the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) makes it the ideal time to kick-start your professional development program, and this ambitious book is the perfect source of inspiration to help you do so.
The arrival of the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) makes it the ideal time to kick-start your professional development program, and this ambitious book is the perfect source of inspiration to help you do so.
 

Discussion and argumentation

By Mary Bigelow

Posted on 2013-11-14

After a lab activity I try to engage students in a discussion of their findings. I use a variety of strategies to involve the students, but I find they don’t really know how to have a meaningful discussion without interruptions, off-topic statements, or inappropriate language. Do you have any suggestions?
—Rosalie, Portland, Oregon
You didn’t mention your grade level, but I suspect this is an issue for both elementary and secondary teachers. Students are exposed to television talk shows in which people yell at and interrupt each other, make unsubstantiated claims, or call each other derogatory names. Texting and tweeting have replaced in-depth, face-to-face conversations. In some classrooms, a “discussion” may be limited to students giving short responses to teacher-directed questions. Students may try to dominate discussions by intimidating or making fun of other students. For many students, it’s much easier to laugh at another’s comment or say “You’re stupid!” than to present a meaningful alternative.
With a heavy focus on reading and writing, the other components of communication—speaking and listening—may be overlooked or taken for granted. And yet, being able to hold a conversation with others is an important skill in the real world. A recent Edutopia blog addresses this topic (Teaching Your Students How to Have a Conversation). These positive conversations contribute to an atmosphere of respect in the classroom, and students should come to understand their role in promoting this respect.
It’s important for teachers to model the expected type of conversation. Demonstrate the language students should use during a discussion: That’s an interesting observation because… Could you please explain that again? I don’t understand. Do you mean that… But what about… What would happen if… It’s been my experience that… I agree/disagree because… I would add that… What evidence do you have for… Could you add more about… (The Edutopia blog mentions that some teachers post these and other discussion stems in the classroom as a reminder for students.) Many of my middle and high school students were self-conscious about using this kind of language. There was a lot of eye-rolling and nervous laughter at first, and I had to be persistent (my students might say relentless) before everyone caught on.
I observed an elementary classroom in which the teacher used several discussion strategies to cut down on interruptions. A quick glance at the interrupter, a shake of the head, or a quiet signal discouraged some. In a particularly effective strategy, the student who was describing the findings of an investigation was given a microphone (a non-functioning one from the technology department). No one was allowed to say anything while that student had the mike. The student could then pass the mike to another who had a question or comment.

In a discussion, listening is as important as talking, and wait time is an effective strategy to promote listening. After you pose a question or discussion topic, wait a 4-5 seconds before calling on a student. Some students (including those for whom English is their second language) may need time to compose their thoughts. This seemingly “dead air” is actually thinking time, and research has shown students’ responses are often at a higher level of complexity. After a student’s response, use more wait time. During these few seconds the student may elaborate on the response, or another student may volunteer to contribute. Before your response, call on other students for follow-up: “Do you have anything to add?” or “Do you agree/disagree?” To acknowledge other students, before your feedback or comment you can say “I noticed your hand was up, too. What were you going to say?”
By creating an environment conducive for discussion in your classroom, you’re setting the stage for Engaging in argument from evidence, one of the Science and Engineering Practices in the Next Generation Science Standards. As students engage in investigations, they develop claims and support them with evidence. They use both verbal and writing skills to critique ideas, propose alternate explanations, and communicate their understandings.
See these NSTA blogs for more information, suggestions, and examples:
Argumentation

Class discussions

Photo: http://www.nsta.org/publications/news/story.aspx?id=52391

After a lab activity I try to engage students in a discussion of their findings. I use a variety of strategies to involve the students, but I find they don’t really know how to have a meaningful discussion without interruptions, off-topic statements, or inappropriate language. Do you have any suggestions?
—Rosalie, Portland, Oregon

 

Problem solving and investigating the properties of materials

By Peggy Ashbrook

Posted on 2013-11-13

Some children dot paint with one finger while others smear with their entire hand.Does the way a child approaches finger-painting or eating a somewhat messy snack tell us anything about how she or he will approach building with blocks or participating in a science activity?
Child holds a cheese-spread covered pretzel stick very carefully.

Child begins to eat the pretzel snack avoiding getting cheese spread all over his hand.Child successfully eats the cheese-spread covered pretzel without getting his hands messy.

There are problem-solving tasks in all of these activities. If we tell children how to do a task, they may not discover other ways, or the best way for their style. Talking about their approach in a discussion may encourage them to try alternative methods and help them build experiences to apply to future problem-solving.
Child works with many different types of materials to construct a container for her favorite food.In the October  and November Early Years columns in Science and Children, I write about exploring the properties of materials and designing a tool to carry heavy objects and a tool (container) to carry a favorite food item. Why not try designing a new way to hold water or carry a slice of pizza? The activity can be part of an on-going investigation into the properties of materials (not only fabric but all kinds of “stuff”). The Next Generation Science Standards for K-12 states that by the end of second grade,   students should know that matter can be described by its observable properties and that different properties are suited to different purposes. Early childhood teachers of toddlers and preschoolers can support their developing understanding with open-ended experiences with a wide variety of materials for pouring, transferring, weighing, bouncing, stacking, balancing, cutting, taping, gluing, stapling, and tying teach children about the properties of “wetness,” texture, weight, stretch, strength, absorption, flexibility, and adherence.
We can support this investigation with discussion and in conversations by asking children what they found out about the material they used, did it work the way they wanted it to, and what materials might they try next time?
There is much to learn about materials through using them for many purposes.

Some children dot paint with one finger while others smear with their entire hand.Does the way a child approaches finger-painting or eating a somewhat messy snack tell us anything about how she or he will approach building with blocks or participating in a science activity?

 

Brush up on your science content knowledge

By Claire Reinburg

Posted on 2013-11-13

Cover of NSTA Press book "Force and Motion: Stop Faking It!At NSTA’s recent fall conferences in Portland and Charlotte, NSTA Press author Bill Robertson led teachers in refresher courses on physical science topics such as sound, light, and force and motion. Robertson’s bestselling book series, Stop Faking It! Finally Understanding Science So You Can Teach It, has been a reliable resource for teachers looking to deepen their content knowledge on selected topics. In the November 2013 issue of Book Beat, we focus on NSTA Press resources that teachers find particularly helpful when they’re looking to strengthen their own science backgrounds.
Stop Faking It! Series
Bill Robertson’s thinking behind his popular and award-winning Stop Faking It! series is that science can be both accessible and fun if information is presented so that people can readily understand it. Download the free chapter “Newton’s First One” from Force and Motion: Stop Faking It! for a lighthearted but substantive introduction to the basic principles of motion. To see more topics Robertson covers in his books, visit the Stop Faking It! series page on the NSTA website, where you can download more sample chapters and activities..
Teacher Learning Opportunities in December
We still have spaces available in our one-day preconference workshops on Wednesday, December 11, 2013, in Denver. Learn how to use formative assessment to transform instruction while simultaneously supporting learning at Page Keeley and Joyce Tugel’s Science Formative Assessment Preconference Workshop. Gain deeper understanding of how to integrate science and reading in your elementary instruction and learn new lessons at Emily Morgan and Karen Ansberry’s Picture-Perfect Science Preconference Workshop. Emily Morgan will also lead an online short course, Moving Toward NGSS: Connecting Science to Common Core With Picture-Perfect Science Lessons, with web sessions on December 2, December 9, and December 16, 2013.
The Science Store Is Open 24/7
To learn more about new resources for science teachers, visit our online Science Store, where you can browse by subject area and download sample chapters from NSTA Press books. Our digital catalog provides another easy way to connect to books and ebooks for teachers of science for kindergarten through college. Be sure to also check out NSTA’s brand-new and highly interactive ebooks, which provide a professional development experience that includes engagement with animations, simulations, and videos on topics from the nature of light to interdependence of life.
To read previous issues of NSTA’s Book Beat and to sign up to receive this monthly enewlsetter, visit the Book Beat archive page on the NSTA website.
 
 

Cover of NSTA Press book "Force and Motion: Stop Faking It!At NSTA’s recent fall conferences in Portland and Charlotte, NSTA Press author Bill Robertson led teachers in refresher courses on physical science topics such as sound, light, and force and motion. Robertson’s bestselling book series, Stop Faking It!

 

NSTA's K-College Journals: Live for November

By Lauren Jonas, NSTA Assistant Executive Director

Posted on 2013-11-13

You’ve turned the clocks back an hour, but you’re still short on time—that’s what most teachers tell us! How can the National Science Teachers Association (NSTA) help? With grade-level journals targeted to your needs, written by educators who know what works. Our November journals are live online (with select articles being free for all, and full content being free to all NSTA members). Browse these issues for classroom-tested ideas, activities you can use tomorrow, and commentary from experts in the field.

CoverScienceAndChildrenNovember2013Science and Children

We all know that assessment should be ongoing, a seamless part of what we do each day in class. When done right, the outcome is rich, yielding an understanding of what students know and can do while allowing us to help them fill in the gaps and then build on their knowledge. This issue offers helpful strategies for developing effective, insightful assessments that support you as you develop instruction.
Featured articles (please note, only those marked “free” are available to nonmembers):

CoverScienceScopeNovember2013Science Scope

Today’s students are bombarded by news not only in print but on screens everywhere around them. Now, more than ever, they need help in analyzing and critiquing the information that they are consuming. This issue is filled with strategies for developing critical consumers of science. We hope you’ll use these activities and lessons to remind students that just because something has been published, doesn’t mean it’s true!
Featured articles (please note, only those marked “free” are available to nonmembers):

CoverTSTNovember2013The Science Teacher

Last month’s issue looked at the impact of the newly released Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) on chemistry instruction, focusing on the first physical science standard, “Matter and Its Interactions” (HS-PS1). This issue, focused on physics and physical science, will consider the NGSS‘s other high school physical science standards: Motion and Stability (HS-PS2), Energy (HS-PS3), and Waves and Their Applications in Technologies for Information Transfer (HS-PS4). Each standard relates performance expectations to disciplinary core ideas, crosscutting concepts, and scientific and engineering practices. This issue brings together several articles on physics that will help science teachers meet the challenges of today’s classroom.
Featured articles (please note, only those marked “free” are available to nonmembers):

CoverJCSTNovember2013Journal of College Science Teaching

Read how the implementation of student-centered learning in introductory biology classes is being facilitated by the use of faculty learning communities at a large state university. Can web-based, collaborative annotation tools improve student participation and learning in academic settings? See the results of one study that focused on the Nota Bene tool. And in a study described in this issue, high school and undergraduate research students taking part in 10-week summer research programs were surveyed to determine their understanding of key concepts in science ethics and whether their understanding changed over the course of their programs.
Featured articles (please note, only those marked “free” are available to nonmembers):

You’ve turned the clocks back an hour, but you’re still short on time—that’s what most teachers tell us! How can the National Science Teachers Association (NSTA) help? With grade-level journals targeted to your needs, written by educators who know what works. Our November journals are live online (with select articles being free for all, and full content being free to all NSTA members). Browse these issues for classroom-tested ideas, activities you can use tomorrow, and commentary from experts in the field.

 

Assessment products and processes

By Mary Bigelow

Posted on 2013-11-07

What is the purpose of an assessment? The featured articles in this issue show assessment as a true part of the instructional process, not an add-on to get a score for a grade. As I read the articles, I was impressed at how the assessments were designed to match the learning goals and the instructional content.
This approach to assessment is described in Assessing for Achievement.* The authors show how formative assessments can be included in each phase of the 5E Instructional Model during a lesson on mixtures and solutions. The authors include samples of student handouts, and their chart showing examples of assessment for each phase of the Model is a wonderful resource for any teacher and any topic. [SciLinks: Mixtures, Solutions] Is It Melting?* (Formative Assessment Probes) has a tool for examining students’ ideas about physical changes in matter (and has an interesting discussion of the difference between melting and dissolving). [SciLinks: Physical Changes, Dissolve]
The first paragraph of Crystal Clear Assessment* should be required reading for educational decision-makers, including the sentence “An effective teacher creates a student-centered learning experience that links essential concepts and skills to students’ current understanding and natural curiosity about the topic.” The authors apply their understandings about students and learning to a 5th grade chemistry unit, using student-designed experiments as a summative activity (rubrics are included). [SciLinks: Physical Properties of Matter]
During a lesson on simple machines, the students featured in Simply Performance Assessment* used basic, inexpensive materials to demonstrate their understanding and use their creativity. The article includes rubrics, a list of materials provided to the students, cooperative learning roles for each team, and photos of some final projects. If you need more background, this month’s Science 101 column is What is the Physics Behind Simple Machines? [SciLinks: Simple Machines]

Do you have students who love to “perform” in class? The authors of And Action!* describe a skit their students created to show their understanding of electricity. The skit also showed off their skills in writing and performing as a way of communicating. The article includes rubrics, photographs of students in action, and a discussion of how these skits were learning and assessment opportunities. [SciLinks: Magnets]
As the authors of Seeing the Science note, English language learners have two challenges in the science classroom: learning science and learning English. They describe a rubric they developed to assess ELL students’ written observations and include examples of student work. The article also includes strategies for supporting these students as writers and scientists. The unit focused on plants, but the rubric could be modified for other topics. Speaking of plants, this months Teaching Through Trade Books column, Pondering Plants*, has trade book and lesson suggestions for engaging K-2 and 3-5 students in a study of parts of a plant, observing plant growth, and investigating factors that affect plant growth. [SciLinks: Factors Affecting Plant Growth, How Do Plants Grow?, Parts of a Plant]
Models (designing, developing, and using) are an important features of the NGSS. This month’s Engineering Encounters column describes how to capitalize on elementary students curiosity and enthusiasm for dropping things (in this case, parachutes!] Who wouldn’t enjoy and learn from this type of activity? And this month’s Early Years column, Are They Getting It?* also has an engineering focus in which students experience a variety of materials and then design a container for food items. The article and lesson note that formative assessment can be as basic as watching students at work and interacting with them with open-ended questions.  [SciLinks: Engineering Structures]
The kindergarten class in Scoring a Goal for Learning used a soccer analogy to guide their teamwork toward meeting a learning goal. The lesson included activities for students to reflect, observe, record, and discuss—all of which are opportunities for formative assessment by teachers (and self-assessment by students). The author of The Sun Is a Star? describes his experiences as a college instructor with a group of third-graders and their misconceptions. He offers suggestions for  using these misconceptions and misunderstandings as opportunities to help students “develop their capacity to make sense of scientific ideas.”
* Many of these articles have extensive resources to share, so check out the Connections for this issue (November 2013). Even if the article does not quite fit with your lesson agenda, there are ideas for handouts, background information sheets, data sheets, rubrics, and other resources.

What is the purpose of an assessment? The featured articles in this issue show assessment as a true part of the instructional process, not an add-on to get a score for a grade. As I read the articles, I was impressed at how the assessments were designed to match the learning goals and the instructional content.

 

#NSTA13 Charlotte Twitter Contest

By Lauren Jonas, NSTA Assistant Executive Director

Posted on 2013-11-05

Join the #NSTA13 Charlotte Twitter contest! If you’ll be attending the National Science Teachers Association’s Conference on Science Education in Charlotte, NC, November 7–9, 2013, tweet for a chance to win NSTA Gear or a $50 Gift Certificate to the onsite Science Store at the Charlotte Convention Center. Tweet the answer to the question “What session/exhibit/talk did you like best at NSTA’s conference in Charlotte?” and put #NSTA13 into your tweet. Those who tweet between 9:00 a.m. ET, Wednesday, November 6, and 2:00 p.m. ET, Friday, November 8, 2013 will be eligible to win. Winners will be selected randomly and must be in the onsite Science Store in the Charlotte Convention Center at 3:30 p.m. ET, Friday, November 8, 2013 to win. Here are the terms and conditions.

Join the #NSTA13 Charlotte Twitter contest! If you’ll be attending the National Science Teachers Association’s Conference on Science Education in Charlotte, NC, November 7–9, 2013, tweet for a chance to win NSTA Gear or a $50 Gift Certificate to the onsite Science Store at the Charlotte Convention Center. Tweet the answer to the question “What session/exhibit/talk did you like best at NSTA’s conference in Charlotte?” and put #NSTA13 into your tweet. Those who tweet between 9:00 a.m.

 

Channeling student enthusiasm

By Mary Bigelow

Posted on 2013-11-03

I’m a new elementary teacher, and I love seeing how students get excited doing hands–on science activities. But the students can get out of hand and I have a hard time focusing them on the activity. Any advice on channeling their enthusiasm with good classroom management would be great!
—Carolyn, Hartford, Connecticut
Most students of any age enjoy being active mentally and physically. As you noted, the key is to capitalize on the enthusiasm of your students in productive ways.
It’s important that students understand a science activity is as much of a learning event as a worksheet, lecture, technology application, or teacher-led discussion (and probably more so). You want them to enjoy the activity, talk with each other, and get up out of their seats (if appropriate), but students need to understand that doing the activity is purposeful and not “free” time. So before they get started, introduce the purpose of the activity and emphasize what students are expected to produce as a result (e.g., a report, a table or graph, a drawing, a model, a list of questions, a summary, or new ideas to share). For example, you could introduce an activity with “Can you remember a time when your heart was beating really fast? [discuss] Today we’re going to explore how your heart rate changes with physical activity. During the investigation you’ll collect data in your notebooks, and then we’ll compare and discuss our findings.” Remind students of any safety issues.
Before the class period, gather all of the materials and make them accessible for students. I found it helpful to have a numbered tray for each group stocked with necessary supplies and an itemized list to help students inventory and return the materials. Keep additional items handy.
Teachers often assume students know how to work cooperatively, but we know assumptions are not always correct! Demonstrate or model the routines you expect (such as getting materials) and appropriate language for group work. For some classes I had to help students practice the routines. One thing that worked for me was to establish teams of 3-4 students. We changed the teams periodically, but students knew where their workstation was and who was in the group (this saved a lot of time and discussion). Each member of the team had a colored dot on their notebook: red, yellow, blue, and green. For an activity, I would say that the red dots would be the recorders, the yellow dots would be the equipment managers, the blue dots would be the question-askers, and the green dots would supervise the clean-up (substitute whatever roles you would have). For the next activity, I would change the roles, so everyone had a chance at each. The roles were clearly defined and I modeled the expectations of each.
During the activity, walk around, ask students about what they’re doing, and reinforce appropriate behaviors. This is also a good time for formative assessments of students’ skills in lab and safety procedures, measurement, and data recording. Immediately address individual students or groups who are off-task or engaging in unsafe, disruptive, or distracting behaviors. If things really start to get out of hand, stop the activity and refocus the students on the activity.
It’s hard to estimate how long a new activity will take. Give yourself and the students enough time, even if you continue the lesson the next day, to avoid rushing through it. If some groups complete the activity in less time than you thought, have some suggestions for extensions or additional ideas to investigate, rather than letting them use this as unstructured time.
Allow enough time to summarize or debrief on the activity (and clean up) before the end of the class period. This gives students time to settle down, focus on what they did, and transition to the next class.
For more ideas, see the July 2009 issue of Science Scope with the theme of Classroom Management. The articles would be appropriate for upper elementary classes, too.
Photo: http://www.flickr.com/photos/rongyos/2686415336/lightbox/

I’m a new elementary teacher, and I love seeing how students get excited doing hands–on science activities. But the students can get out of hand and I have a hard time focusing them on the activity. Any advice on channeling their enthusiasm with good classroom management would be great!
—Carolyn, Hartford, Connecticut

Subscribe to
Asset 2