Teachers and families across the country are facing a new reality of providing opportunities for students to do science through distance and home learning. The Daily Do is one of the ways NSTA is supporting teachers and families with this endeavor. Each weekday, NSTA will share a sensemaking task teachers and families can use to engage their students in authentic, relevant science learning. We encourage families to make time for family science learning (science is a social process!) and are dedicated to helping students and their families find balance between learning science and the day-to-day responsibilities they have to stay healthy and safe.
Interested in learning about other ways NSTA is supporting teachers and families? Visit the NSTA homepage.
Sensemaking is actively trying to figure out how the world works (science) or how to design solutions to problems (engineering). Students do science and engineering through the science and engineering practices. Engaging in these practices necessitates students be part of a learning community to be able to share ideas, evaluate competing ideas, give and receive critique, and reach consensus. Whether this community of learners is made up of classmates or family members, students and adults build and refine science and engineering knowledge together.
Today's task, How did the moth population change?, creates an opportunity for students to look at examples of how different factors affect shifts in organisms population. Students engage in science and engineering practices - including the use graphical data - to figure out why some populations may shifts over time.
This task has been designed in order to be used by students, parents, and teachers in distance and home learning. While older students could complete this task independently, we encourage younger students to work virtually with peers or in the home with family members.
Documenting populations are done for many reasons. State agencies, environmentalists, and many others keep track of populations of both plants and animals to ensure that the ecosystems within an area stay healthy. When a dramatic shift happens in a population it often raises questions about what is going on. For today's Daily Do we will explore the shift in a population of moths to try to figure out what is going on in the ecosystem to cause such a dramatic shift in population.
Guidance: Students-as-scientists take on the role of biologist. The goal is to get students thinking about patterns they are seeing in the data, to ask investigative questions to figure out what is going on with the population. Presenting a phenomenon and asking students to generate questions about it creates a need to figure out the answer to those questions. This is authentic engagement and a powerful learning process (unlike "learning about" populations and ecosystems).
Experiencing the Phenomenon:
Have students analyze the data below. Ask students to record what they notice about the population. Our goal here is to promote student thinking around the science practice of analyzing and interpreting data. Next, ask students what patterns they notice in the data and have them record any questions they have about the moth data. ALL student questions are okay at this point. Our goal is to motivate curiosity and not distinguish between "good questions" and "bad questions" or "right questions" and "wrong questions". Common questions will arise for most students, which is what this task builds on.
Investigative questions are common questions kids may ask after they are introduced to the phenomena. Although questions may vary, many students are curious about what is going on with the moth population and why it shifted so dramatically.
Guidance: It is important to allow time for thinking. Many students have ideas and questions but need time to formulate their idea or question into words. Some students may also benefit from writing things down first before they share. As adults we may be tempted to give them questions we feel might be important to explore, however, we need to refrain from this and allow our students to practice asking their own questions. Our goal here is for students to consider all of the different factors that may have noticed before but never really thought about.
Students may make connections to previous concepts depending on their grade level. For example, elementary students may mention that moths come from a caterpillar so maybe something is happening to the caterpillars. Middle school students may know that there are different interactions that can happen within an ecosystem that can cause a shift in the population of an organism. Other things students may mention are there are things that eat both caterpillars and moths, there are chemicals that people use to kill insects, and that there are several things that all animals need to survive.
Student Ideas and Background Knowledge
Based on our initial questions, we think we need to figure out some things about these light- and dark-colored moths. Why are they colored differently? First, here are some basic things we need to know about them:
Guidance: The information (bulleted items) above can be shared with the students or students could do some basic research about peppered moth. You might also share this article, Peppered Moths, with students.
Guidance: Brainstorming is a great way to get students thinking and collaborating. If you are doing this at home, try a brainstorming discussion to get ideas out. If you are doing this with a group of students have them brainstorm independently first then share their ideas with a partner or small group.
Ask students to brainstorm ideas about what they think might be happening that would cause a shift in color within the moth population. Common ideas include:
Prompt students to think about the population of moths as a whole, using questions such as:
Ask students which idea we should investigate. Students will likely say we should figure out if something is eating the light-colored moths.
Tell student that birds eat moths so to help us figure out what is going with the moth population you are going to gather some data. Have students engaged in the Peppered Moth Simulation in order to gather some data on light moth and dark moth populations.
After each game have students record the summary percents of light moths and dark moths which appear in a black text box when the game is complete. Ask students to create a data table or t-chart to keep their data organized.
Have students play at least 2 rounds in each of the colored forests (more rounds are better if there is time). If you are doing this as a class, consider having students share their data as part of a class data chart.
After the data has been collected, have students identify any patterns they notice. They should notice that dark moths on light trees get eaten at a higher percent than light moths on light trees and vice versa.
After looking at the patterns in the data, engage students in a 'taking stock' discussion. Ask students what they know about the moths so far that would help them figure out the lesson question.
Have students discuss their ideas about why the population is shifting. Students will most likely say that the population is shifting because birds are eating the light-colored moths instead of the dark-colored ones.
Next, ask them why? Why would birds all of a sudden switch? Ask students what else could be going on in the ecosystem to cause this shift? Have students share their ideas.
After students share their ideas, have them read Natural Selection, which provides more information about the moths and where they lived.
Have a discussion around the question, What did we figure out from the reading, and how does it help up explain the data we analyzed at the beginning of the lesson?
During the discussion, students should demonstrate they have figured out:
Last, have students think about how human activities continue to change environments. Ask students to think about how human actions affect populations of plants and/or animals in the area where you live.
Some organisms students can research include:
NSTA has created a Why did the moth population change? resource collection to support teachers and families using this task. If you're an NSTA member, you can add this collection to your library by clicking ADD TO MY LIBRARY located near the top of the page.
NSTA Press BookUncovering Student Ideas in Science, Volume 2, Second Edition: 25 More Formative Assessment Probes
COMING IN APRIL 2021; NOW AVAILABLE FOR PREORDER “Leave no alternative science idea unchallenged!” could be the slogan of this second edition o...