A marine microbiology board game-based activity for high school science classrooms
By Quinn Washburn, Sarah Wolf, Jay Well, Stephen Noell, Chih-Ping Lee, Luis M. Bolaños, Stephen J. Giovannoni, and Christopher P. Suffridge
Climate change is a challenge that all students will encounter; in fact, they are dealing with its early effects now. It is important that students understand the role the ocean plays in mitigating climate change, and how every person on this planet is uniquely connected to the ocean. Identifying these connections can be challenging for students in rural or underserved areas, many of whom do not live by, or interact with, the ocean. Through the use of the board game Oligotrophic and the accompanying lesson, we hope to show students their personal connection to the oceans, the carbon cycle, and climate change.
Marine microbes influence the global climate through a process called the microbial carbon pump. Oceans cover 70% of Earth’s surface and have an average depth of 4,000 meters. Every milliliter of seawater contains over a million microbial cells. In the surface ocean, most of these cells are microbial plants called phytoplankton, which capture atmospheric carbon dioxide and absorb it into their biomass. When these cells die, they sink into the deep ocean, effectively removing (or pumping) carbon dioxide from the atmosphere for thousands to millions of years.
The efficiency of the microbial carbon pump is determined by the interactions of phytoplankton with abiotic factors (nutrients) and other types of microbes (heterotrophic bacteria, viruses, etc.). The microbial carbon pump is a key portion of the global carbon cycle and has been largely responsible for the removal of excess anthropogenic carbon dioxide from the atmosphere for the past 200 years, successfully mitigating the impacts of climate change. However, anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions have exceeded the capacity of the microbial carbon pump, and as a result climate change is progressing at a rapid pace.
Students investigate these critical ecological and oceanic processes by playing Oligotrophic, which simulates real-life microbial interactions that form the basis of the microbial carbon pump. Oligotrophic is an easy-to-learn, strategic tile-placement game where players compete to place biomass the fastest. In the game, players select and play hexagonal cards based on actual microorganisms to accumulate biomass, achieve bonuses, and take biomass from other microorganisms they encounter (Figures 1 and 2).
For this activity, students form groups and play Oligotrophic several times in increasingly complex simulations. In each they make predictions and measure the biomass of each type of organism represented in the game. Students track the movement of biomass throughout the microbial food web and learn how marine microbes mediate the uptake of anthropogenic carbon via the Microbial Carbon Pump.
After each round concludes, students take quantitative measurements of the biomass in their systems. Groups then perform experiments using Oligotrophic, where they introduce a change, such as removing all heterotrophs from the system, and play the game again to understand the ecological impact of their introduced change. Using Oligotrophic as a model, students take what they learn in previous rounds, make hypotheses about the outcome of this change, then test their hypotheses and share results with their classmates.
This reinforces Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) science and engineering practices (SEP) such as data gathering from a model and using it to make informed predictions about the outcomes of the changes they introduce. Scientists apply these same skills when they make predictions about how global climate change will impact the ocean, including the Microbial Carbon Pump, which effects the ocean’s ability to uptake anthropogenic carbon dioxide.
The Oligotrophic game and lesson plan has been piloted with a network of rural Oregon high school science teachers through a partnership with the OSU SMILE Program. Teachers implemented this lesson plan with their students and provided feedback and suggestions that helped us improve lesson content and create detailed educational supports that allow teachers to scaffold for the needs of their students. The lesson plan also allows for different levels of engagement from learning game play to increasingly challenging simulations using Oligotrophic as a model to understand carbon cycling in the ocean.
All resources and materials required for this lesson plan are included as supplemental files and are listed and described in Table 1. The files to print Oligotrophic are provided in Supplemental 8. Oligotrophic can be adapted to distance learning by using an online tabletop game simulator (Table 1). Using this online platform, students can play Oligotrophic and complete the associated activities virtually with their classmates
|Table 1. Resources and materials provided for the Oligotrophic Lesson Plan.|
The lesson plan that accompanies Oligotrophic connects to NGSS performance expectations HS-LS1-5 and HS-LS2-1. Students will gain a greater understanding of ocean microbes, including the following:
The activity consists of three parts:
An introductory presentation provides background information about marine microbial ecology and the global carbon cycle (Supplemental 7; see Online Connections). This presentation also provides students with an overview of how Oligotrophic is played. Microbial exploration expert groups then build on the introductory presentation by utilizing a flipped classroom approach that allows students to explore an aspect of microbial ecology, and then teach the rest of the class about their findings.
All the cards in Oligotrophic represent actual organisms, nutrients, and processes in the ocean. The way the card abilities are designed to interact with each other and the way biomass cubes move between cards during the simulation is based on the way these organisms and processes interact in nature. Student expert groups select one of the card-types to research (nutrients, phototrophs, heterotrophs, or viruses) and share their findings with the rest of the class. Handouts with detailed information and resources on each of the card types are provided in Supplemental 6 (see Online Connections).
Once students are primed with background information, they are ready to use Oligotrophic to experiment with the way marine microbes interact. To test their understanding of a system, scientists often build models of the system. Models show how one part of a system interacts with another. We have built the Oligotrophic activity to be a model to simulate the way marine microbial communities function. While Oligotrophic takes the form of a board game, there is little actual difference between the way this game functions and the way large-scale global models function.
The experimental portion is split into three simulations, each offering increasing complexity. Students are first asked to make predictions (generate hypotheses) based on their knowledge from the exploration section and any previous simulation rounds. They then run the simulation (play Oligotrophic) to generate data. Finally, they plot their data and compare it to their predictions to generate conclusions. Full details of this section can be found in the provided lesson plan (Supplemental 1; see Online Connections). A student worksheet is also provided (Supplemental 2; see Online Connections), as are example responses (Supplemental 3; see Online Connections), and a rubric for the final assessment (Supplemental 4; see Online Connections).
The goal of the first simulation is for students to become familiar with simulation gameplay and understand how marine microbes interact. Prior to beginning the simulation, students predict which card-types will accumulate the most biomass. Predictions should be recorded on the student worksheet (Supplemental 2; see Online Connections) and should be based on what students learned in expert groups. Each group then runs the simulation (plays the game). At the end of the simulation, each group will count and record the number of biomass pieces on each card-type on the provided worksheet (Supplemental 2; see Online Connections) and the live datasheet (Supplemental 5; see Online Connections) which will generate graphs automatically when data is added. Once all groups have finished the simulation, students will complete the simulation 1 worksheet activities asking them to compare the data they generated with their predictions.
The goal of the second simulation is to assess the way microbial community interactions change over time by increasing the sampling frequency of the microbial community. Based on their results/observations from Simulation 1, students should predict how the biomass distribution will change during each turn in Simulation 2. Predictions should be recorded on the provided worksheet (Supplemental 2). Each group then runs the simulation. At the end of each round (each player has played 1 card), the number and location of all biomass cubes on the board is recorded in the provided worksheet and live datasheet (Supplemental 2 and 5). Students should take notes on the direction the biomass is flowing; for example, biomass from phototrophs may be taken by heterotrophs. Following Simulation 2, each group completes the associated worksheet activities (Supplemental 2) and shares their ending biomass distribution with the rest of the class. The teacher then asks students for their observations about how biomass is flowing and what sorts of interactions students observed.
The goal of Simulation 3 is to conduct an experiment. Since the simulation is a model of a natural system, experiments can be conducted just as in the lab. If the model is built correctly, the results from the model-based experiment will match the lab-based experiment. For this experiment, each group excludes one card-type from their simulation deck (e.g., removing all virus cards). The questions asked in this experiment are: How does the ecosystem (simulation) change when one class of organisms is removed? Can a stable ecosystem (simulation) exist if one class of organisms is missing?
Prior to running the simulation, each group should make predictions (generate hypotheses) based on the above questions and their results/observations from Simulations 1 and 2. At this point in the activity, students should have a good idea about how biomass moves through trophic levels, and should be able to predict how biomass will be distributed in their Simulation 3 when one class of cards is removed.
Each group then runs the simulation. At the end of each round (each player has played 1 card), students will use the provided worksheet and live datasheet (Supplemental 2 and 5) to record the number and location of all biomass cubes on the board. Students should take notes on the direction the biomass is flowing. After the completion of Simulation 3, each group completes the worksheet activities (Supplemental 2) to determine if their predictions match their observations. Each group then shares its findings with the rest of the class. Since each group excluded a different card-type, post-simulation discussion will focus on the role that the organisms included in each card-type plays in the ecosystem.
Student understanding is assessed as they work though the questions and activities in the provided student worksheet (Supplemental 2). Much of the assessment in this activity connects to SEPs such as Developing and Using Models and Using Mathematics and Computational Thinking; and Cross Cutting Concepts (CCC) such as Energy and Matter, and Scale, Proportion and Quantity. Before running each simulation, students make predictions; during each simulation students record their data on the provided worksheet and datasheets (Supplemental 2 and 5). After each simulation, students plot and interpret the data they collected. They are asked to compare their predictions with their observations and make informed conclusions. Students also reflect on the underlying ecosystem processes modeled by the simulations, and how those processes might influence their observations.
Once all the simulations have been completed, students synthesize the concepts they have learned in a series of broad, discussion-based ecosystem-level questions. These questions are designed to either be completed individually or as part of a class-based discussion. Potential answers for all portions of the worksheet (including hypothetical simulation results) and a rubric to gauge understanding for the concluding questions are provided in Supplemental 3 and 4 (see Online Connections).
Climate change is an existential threat to humanity, and we need to prepare young people with the knowledge to understand its impact. We developed an engaging and thought-provoking learning activity for students to explore and experiment with a major global process that controls our climate: the microbial carbon pump. It is our hope that this lesson will provide a way for a student who has never been to the ocean to begin to conceptualize their understanding of the carbon cycle, the ocean, climate change, and themself. We have witnessed this through our piloting of Oligotrophic within Oregon classrooms.
As one teacher who piloted the lesson said, Oligotrophic “really feeds into the kinds of systems thinking that is so critical to literacy in and beyond science. Because the game is social, students get a chance to share and develop their understanding and language skills while playing.” We were excited to hear student conversations that demonstrated a more detailed understanding of the carbon cycle. We frequently observed students discussing the implications of climate change caused by anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions, and how their day-to-day choices could impact the future of our planet. Through Oligotrophic and the accompanying lesson, we hope to give teachers and students a new appreciation for marine microorganisms and their importance in the global carbon cycle. ■
The Giovannoni Lab at Oregon State University works in partnership with the OSU Office of Precollege Programs, Science and Math Investigative Learning Experiences (SMILE) program to develop innovative instructional modules, such as Oligotrophic, creating a bridge between our research, the ocean, climate change, and K-12 classrooms. The mission of this partnership is to increase the success of underrepresented and underserved students, promote college readiness, and improve access to higher education including pathways into STEM programs. Our educational outreach is funded as a broader impacts component of several NSF grants to SJG (OCE 1436865, DEB 1639033, and OCE 1948163).
Supplemental 1—Lesson plan: https://bit.ly/3l3BOMb
Supplemental 2—Student worksheets: https://bit.ly/3qAEAtJ
Supplemental 3—Student worksheet examples: https://bit.ly/3vbQ1eR
Supplemental 4—Rubric: https://bit.ly/3l3NC13
Supplemental 5—Datasheet: https://bit.ly/3veFyiA
Supplemental 6—Fact sheets: https://bit.ly/3l0Hzuj
Supplemental 7—Oligotrophic Powerpoint: https://bit.ly/3cmWVVM
Supplemental 8—Complete game and rules: https://bit.ly/3buVbe6
Quinn Washburn (email@example.com) and Sarah Wolf are graduate students, Jay Well is a SMILE program administrator, Stephen Noell, Chih-Ping Lee, Luis M. Bolaños, and Christopher P. Suffridge (firstname.lastname@example.org) are postdoctoral researchers, and Stephen J. Giovannoni is a distinguished professor at Oregon State University in Corvallis, OR.
Web SeminarWeb Seminar: Are your Lab SOPs in Place for a Safer School Year?, September 16, 2021
Join us on Thursday, September 16, 2021, from 7:00 PM to 8:00 PM ET, to learn how teachers of science can prepare for a safe return to school....